Skip to content
All Articles

Guides · November 10, 2026

How to Choose an Engagement Ring You Will Love

Laura's Three Rules for the Perfect Ring

After 25 years of helping couples find and create engagement rings, Laura Whisenhunt has distilled her advice down to three straightforward rules. Follow them and you will walk away with a ring you love for a lifetime.

1. Choose a Stone You Love

This sounds simple, but it matters more than any trend or recommendation. The center stone is what catches the light and catches your eye every single day. Whether it is a round brilliant, an emerald cut, a cushion, or an oval, choose the shape and the sparkle that speaks to you.

At Exclusive Custom Jewelry, every loose diamond is certified by GIA or IGI, whether it is a natural or lab grown stone. That certification means you know exactly what you are getting: the cut, the color, the clarity, and the carat weight, all verified by an independent lab.

2. Choose a Design That Fits Your Lifestyle

A ring should be beautiful and practical. If you work with your hands, a low profile setting with a bezel or flush mount might be a smarter choice than a tall cathedral prong. If you love vintage style, Laura can sketch an intricate halo or milgrain band that still sits comfortably.

That is the beauty of custom design. Nothing is off the shelf. Laura will sketch ideas based on your daily life and your aesthetic so the ring works for the way you actually live.

3. Choose Something That Fits Your Budget

One of the biggest misconceptions is that you need to spend a certain amount. Laura disagrees. Everyone deserves something beautiful and uniquely theirs at any budget. The custom design process at Exclusive Custom Jewelry lets you adjust stone size, metal type, and design details to land in the right range.

Financing is available through Synchrony, which gives you additional flexibility.

Start With a Free Consultation

The best way to follow all three rules is to sit down with Laura in our Edmond showroom. The initial design consultation is completely free with no pressure. Bring inspiration photos, a rough budget, or just an open mind. Laura will guide you from there.

Private after hours appointments are also available if you want the showroom to yourself.

Call or text (405) 705 7728 to schedule.

Ready to Start Your Journey?

Schedule a free, no pressure design consultation with Laura at our Edmond showroom.

Schedule Your Free Consultation

More from the Blog

Let's Design It Together

Sit down with Laura for a free, no pressure design consultation in our Edmond showroom. Private after hours appointments are available.

Schedule Your FREE Consultation